Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21 Updated

Mergers, acquisitions and startup deals, and what they mean.

Preference Demand Letter: Why a Bankrupt Customer Wants Money Back

A preference demand letter says a bankrupt customer's trustee wants back payments made before filing, usually within 90 days. See the defenses and next steps.

A lawyer discusses legal documents with clients in an office setting.
Photo: Pavel Danilyuk / Pexels

A preference demand letter is a request from a bankruptcy trustee or a company’s estate asking a creditor to return money the debtor paid shortly before filing for bankruptcy. Under Section 547 of the US Bankruptcy Code, payments made in the 90 days before the filing can be clawed back, and the window is one year for insiders such as owners and relatives. The letter is a demand, not a court judgment, and many recipients have legal defenses.

Receiving one does not mean you did anything wrong. The rule exists because paying one creditor in full shortly before bankruptcy can leave others with less, and the law aims to share what is left more evenly.

Why does a bankrupt customer want money back?

The goal is fairness among creditors. When a company files for bankruptcy, its assets are meant to be divided by priority and, within a class, in proportion. If the company paid some suppliers just before filing, those suppliers received more than they would have in the bankruptcy. The trustee, or a creditors’ trust created under a Chapter 11 plan, can sue to recover those payments and put them back in the pot for everyone.

These recovery claims are called avoidance actions. Law firms handling them often send letters to many vendors at once, based on the debtor’s payment records, which is why the amount demanded can be large and the letter can look generic. Often the letter is the opening move in a negotiation, not the final number.

What does the trustee have to prove?

The estate generally has to show several things about the payment:

  • It went to a creditor, for a debt the debtor already owed.
  • It was made while the debtor was insolvent. The Code presumes insolvency during the 90 days before filing, so the creditor usually has to rebut that.
  • It happened within the 90-day window, or the one-year window for insiders.
  • It let the creditor receive more than it would have received in a liquidation without the payment.

If any element is missing, the claim fails. Secured creditors, for example, often did not receive more than they would have anyway, because their collateral covers the debt.

What defenses can a vendor use?

Section 547(c) lists defenses that reduce or eliminate a claim. The common ones are:

  • Ordinary course of business. The payment fit the normal terms and timing between you and the debtor, or the usual terms in your industry. Payment history from before the 90 days is the main evidence.
  • Subsequent new value. After receiving a payment, you shipped more goods or services on credit that were not paid in full. That new value can offset the payment.
  • Contemporaneous exchange. You were paid at the same time as you delivered something new, such as cash on delivery.
  • Small transfers. The law sets a minimum aggregate amount before a claim against a non-consumer debt can be brought, and the figure is adjusted from time to time.
  • Critical vendor and other court orders. If the court approved payment of your claim early, or the plan released claims against vendors, the demand may not stand.

What should I do when I get the letter?

Do not ignore it, and do not simply pay it. The deadline for the estate to sue is generally two years after the bankruptcy filing, so a letter that goes unanswered often leads to a lawsuit. Take these steps:

  1. Note the response deadline in the letter and contact a bankruptcy attorney before the date passes.
  2. Collect your invoices, contracts, purchase orders, payment records and emails with the debtor, going back at least a year before the filing.
  3. Compare each payment in the letter against your records. Check that the dates, amounts and invoice numbers match, and that the payer is the debtor and not a different company.
  4. Build a timeline of normal payment habits, and list any new shipments after each payment.
  5. Ask the other side for supporting data, then respond in writing with your defenses.

Many claims are settled for less than the original demand once defenses are documented. Settlement terms are specific to each case, so get advice before agreeing to anything. General information on how the process works is on the US Courts website.

What happens if I pay?

A creditor that returns a preference payment gets its original claim back as an unsecured claim against the estate. That means you can claim the amount you gave back, but unsecured creditors usually recover only part of what they are owed, if anything. Paying the trustee therefore often means a real loss.

The same ideas come up in other bankruptcy topics. The way a company sells its business is covered in how a Section 363 sale works, and another rule that forces insiders to return money is explained in the Section 16(b) short-swing profit rule.

Quick answers

Is a preference demand letter a lawsuit?

No. It is a request, usually sent before any court case. If the matter is not resolved, the estate can file an adversary proceeding in the bankruptcy court.

Do I have to give back payments for goods I already delivered?

Not automatically. Delivery matters because new value you gave after a payment can offset it, and normal-course payments are protected.

Can an individual get one?

Yes. Employees, landlords, lenders and family members who received payments before a filing can be targeted, and insiders face the longer one-year window.

Does this apply to consumers who paid a bankrupt business?

Preference claims are aimed at payments the debtor made to creditors, not at customers who paid for goods or services. Customer questions about gift cards and returns are covered in warranties, returns and loyalty points when a retailer goes bankrupt.